Book Endings We’d Like to Change

A Pigeon and a Boy
By Meir Shalev

One of the most beautiful and transporting novels I read last year was Meir Shalev’s A Pigeon and a Boy (Pantheon Books, 2007). In it, Shalev tells two connected stories of love and longing: that of Yair, a middle-aged tour guide in modern day Jerusalem whose new-found love helps him transcend a disintegrating marriage and profound grief for his recently deceased mother; and that of The Baby, a homing pigeon handler killed during the 1948 War Of Independence. I loved everything about this novel: I loved the characters, I loved the story, I loved the setting, I loved the exquisite romance that evolved between The Baby and a young woman via the love letters they sent by pigeon.

Ah, but the ending… I cannot say anything at all without spoiling it, except to say that two events left me with tears welling up in my eyes – one tragic yet lovely and perfect, and the other tragic and punch-in-the-gut surprising. Couldn’t it have been any other way? Couldn’t the author have made a different choice? Couldn’t he have just let this character – let us – be happy?

Except then, of course, it would not have been the same story. As much as my heart still wishes for the Sad Thing not to have happened, I wouldn’t really have changed it one bit.

-Jennifer M. Kaufman

3 thoughts on “Book Endings We’d Like to Change

  1. I think that for me, it would be The Time Traveler's Wife. In case someone hasn't read it, I won't say what I would change…but I suspect most who've read it know what I would change.

  2. I would change that one too, aliceisforever.
    And I totally agree with "IT". I was GLUED to that book (except that night a friend decided to raise a balloon right outside my bedroom window) and when I came to the end, I was poised for something equally dramatic and spellbinding and I got — a spider???? Pah-lu-heeze.

  3. On Friday Night Knitting Club–It was a total letdown when the protagonist kicked the bucket. Didn't even bother to read the others in the series.

Comments are closed.